Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies baked to golden perfection then layered with our signature cloud-like vanilla cream. This is the nostalgic classic you remember, reimagined with richer flavor, better ingredients, and that fresh-from-the-oven bakery touch.
Each pie is generously filled, perfectly balanced - soft, creamy, and melt-in-your-mouth with every bite. Whether you're treating yourself, sharing with friends, or sending a sweet gift, this box delivers comfort that tastes like home.
✨ Handcrafted in small batches
✨ Freshly baked to order
✨ Sealed for peak freshness and softness
✨ Made with wholesome ingredients
✨ Baked in a Virginia Department of Agriculture & Consumer Services (VDACS) inspected and permitted kitchen
Includes: 6 or 12 pack of Oatling Oatmeal Pecan Cream Pies
🎁 Every Oatling Cream Pie 12-Pack order currently includes a complimentary collectible Oatie figurine while supplies last. Follow Oatie's adventures on Instagram @theoatlingbakery.
Ingredients: Butter (pasteurized cream, natural flavorings), oats, wheat flour, (unbleached hard wheat flour, malted barley flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), brown sugar, creme (corn syrup, sugar, egg white), confectioners’ sugar (sugar, corn starch), pecans, eggs, granulated sugar, molasses, vanilla extract (organic glycerin, water, organic vanilla bean extractives), baking soda, salt, cinnamon.
CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGG, PECAN
Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 15 reviews.
I was so excited to receive my order and it did not disappoint. Big cookies with lots of filling! They have the homey feel to them. I will order again and highly recommend and will be sending gifts to friends around the holidays. These make perfect gifts.
I finally tried these oatmeal cream pies from The Oatling Bakery and omg… absolutely worth it 😭 The cookies were super soft, the filling was perfect, and they honestly tasted way better than any store bought version I’ve had. You can tell a lot of care goes into them. My favorite was the pecan oatling! Definitely recommend trying them if you get the chance 👏
Delicious
Flavor is as good ... However they were mailed during the summer with no ice packets not was it sent overnight to prevent melting so my oatmeal pies showed up melted
Cozy is the only word I can think of.
The soft moist cookie and pecans is everything.
After I ate 4 over the last 3 days...My husband 'just wanted one bite.' Yeah... sure 😂
Coffee + this = elite morning.
I didn't think pecan would be MY flavor but here we are.
I bought these on a whim and was genuinely impressed. Shipping was quicker than what was mentioned on the site.
These have that imperfect, handmade look I love. It had the comforting taste of a from-scratch recipe. A very easy five stars from me.
Heard about these through a friend's group. I was blown away. They are so tasty and fresh and the filling is super airy and not greasy.
Packed with flavor, they must use a lot of Pecans!! Also, can we talk about the adorable bakery helper, Oatie, that is all over the socials causing mayhem left and right! Please keep creating those clips they are so entertaining.
Softest chewiest tastiest cookies EVER!
The first bite was soft, rich, and comforting. That buttery pecans is exactly what I hoped for. The slightly rustic shape made it feel genuinely handmade. Delivery was prompt, and everything inside was neat and intact. This box did not last long in our house.
