Shipping and Freshness

Every Oatling oatmeal cream pie is baked fresh and carefully packaged to arrive in perfect condition.

Heat-Sealed Freshness
Each cookie is sealed in a specialty heat-sealed freshness bag to lock in flavor and maintain the soft, chewy texture of our oatmeal cookies and fluffy cream filling.

Protective Packaging
Orders are packed in sturdy corrugated shipping boxes to ensure your cookies arrive safely without damage during transit.

Fresh Baking & Shipping
Orders typically ship within 2 business days of being placed. During high order volumes, processing may take slightly longer as each batch is baked fresh to maintain the highest quality and freshness.

Delivery Date Advisory
We bake-to-order and limit transit time so oatmeal cream pies are fresh upon arrival. Shipping dates and pricing are determined by location and availability. We try our best to deliver orders as requested, but the mail carrier may experience unexpected delays or an earlier than expected delivery. We recommend selecting a delivery date before your occasion/event if you would like delivery by a specific date.

How Long They Stay Fresh
Thanks to our heat-sealed packaging, Oatling cream pies stay fresh for up to 2 weeks at room temperature when sealed. For the best taste and texture, we recommend enjoying them sooner.