This is what Little Debbie SHOULD taste like! These are unbelievably soft. The fluffy cream is unreal. Huge cookies. Worth every penny.
Skip to product information
Oatling Original Oatmeal Cream Pies
$46.00
Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies baked to golden perfection then layered with our signature cloud-like vanilla cream. This is the nostalgic classic you remember, reimagined with richer flavor, better ingredients, and that fresh-from-the-oven bakery touch.
Each pie is generously filled, perfectly balanced - soft, creamy, and melt-in-your-mouth with every bite. Whether you're treating yourself, sharing with friends, or sending a sweet gift, this box delivers comfort that tastes like home.
Why You'll Love Our Oatlings
✨ Handcrafted in small batches
✨ Freshly baked to order
✨ Sealed for peak freshness and softness
✨ Made with wholesome ingredients
✨ Baked in a Virginia Department of Agriculture & Consumer Services (VDACS) inspected and permitted kitchen
Includes: 6 or 12- Pack of Original Oatmeal Cream Pies
🎁 Every Oatmeal Cream Pie 12-Pack order currently includes a complimentary collectible Oatie figurine while supplies last. Follow Oatie's adventures on Instagram @theoatlingbakery.
Ingredients: Butter (pasteurized cream, natural flavorings), oats, wheat flour, (unbleached hard wheat flour, malted barley flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), brown sugar, creme (corn syrup, sugar, egg white), confectioners' sugar (sugar, corn starch), eggs, granulated sugar, molasses, vanilla extract (organic glycerin, water, organic vanilla bean extractives), baking soda, salt, cinnamon.
CONTAINS: WHEAT, MILK, EGG
You may also like
Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 5.0 / 5 from 25 reviews.
Gone already!
Sooo good.
These are the best oatmeal cream pies ever!
Was purchased for a birthday gift and well received with rave reviews!
When the package arrived there was a little spill over of the cream in the boom of the individually sealed cookies but we refrigerated them briefly when they arrived and waited for them to go back to room temperature after we took them out of the fridge and they were so worth the wait! Soft and fresh.
If I could live on these I would! They are so tasty and fresh.
The cream is ridiculously light and balanced with the cookie.
SO much softer than I expected.
Already hiding these from everyone else in the house. sorry not sorry...
I literally stalked the tracking because of the summer heat notice and I was really excited lol. Grabbed the box before it sat outside.
Saw a Facebook ad at 11:30 pm and somehow ended up ordering. Zero regrets.
SO soft. Like... ridiculously soft.
OMG...this is what Little Debbie was meant to be 😂
I found these through a TikTok video. I absolutely love the packaging. The cream was fluffy (just like the videos!) and the oatmeal cookies were soft and fresh.
I watched the tracking email because of the summer heat notice on the website and brought the box inside right away. There was a tiny belt of melted frosting on the bottom but I was able to refrigerate and they were amazing. The cream was fluffy and the oatmeal cookies practically melted together.
Soft, cozy, and exactly the kind of treat I wanted with coffee. These are going on my gift list.
Saw an Instagram reel and ordered immediately. The old-school oatmeal flavor came through, and then the fluffy sweetness.
I could not believe how big these were in person. The filling made the whole thing feel extra special while still tasting homemade. These would make such a good gift.
This was one of the freshest shipped desserts I have tried. There was plenty of cream in every bite, and it tasted balanced rather than overly sweet. You can tell the recipe is focused on real, familiar ingredients. They arrived quickly, packed neatly, and tasted fantastic.
The texture was what won me over immediately. The cream filling was fluffy, smooth, and generous without taking over the cookie. There was no artificial aftertaste at all, just butter, oats, spice, and sweetness. These are going on my repeat-order list.
This is the kind of dessert that feels homemade in the best possible way. There was plenty of cream in every bite, and it tasted balanced rather than overly sweet. Everything tasted natural and balanced rather than processed. They were worth every penny.
Nothing about these tasted mass produced. Even for TWO weeks, the texture was still soft and moist. The cream was thick enough to feel indulgent but still airy. You can tell the recipe is focused on real, familiar ingredients. I already know I need another box for the holidays.
You can tell real care goes into every batch. The packaging kept every cookie intact. I especially loved how the filling stayed soft and creamy even after delivery. My family finished the box much faster than planned.
The cookies had that soft, just-baked quality I always look for. The cream was thick enough to feel indulgent but still airy. These would make such a good gift.