Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies baked to golden perfection and layered with our signature fluffy vanilla cream filling. These gourmet oatmeal cream pies bring back everything you loved about the classic treat, reimagined with richer flavor, simple wholesome ingredients, and a fresh baked bakery touch.
Each Oatling is handcrafted in small batches, generously filled, and perfectly balanced with soft oatmeal cookies and creamy filling in every bite. Whether you're treating yourself, sharing with friends, sending a thoughtful gift, or stocking up for the week, this assortment delivers comfort in its most delicious form.
✨ Handcrafted in small batches
✨ Freshly baked to order
✨ Sealed for peak freshness and softness
✨ Made with wholesome ingredients
✨ Baked in a Virginia Department of Agriculture & Consumer Services (VDACS) inspected and permitted kitchen
Available in 6 Pack and 12 Pack Assortments
Flavors Included:
Original – our nostalgic classic featuring soft oatmeal cookies and fluffy vanilla cream filling
Chocolate Chip – packed with mini chocolate chips for a richer, more indulgent bite
Coconut – lightly sweet with a delicate coconut finish
Pecan – warm, buttery, and perfectly nutty
6 Pack Includes:
• 3 Original
• 1 Chocolate Chip
• 1 Coconut
• 1 Pecan
12 Pack Includes:
• 3 Original
• 3 Chocolate Chip
• 3 Coconut
• 3 Pecan
🎁 Every Oatmeal Cream Pie 12-Pack order currently includes a complimentary collectible Oatie figurine while supplies last. Follow Oatie's adventures on Instagram @theoatlingbakery.
Please Note:
Our Oatling assortments come as listed and cannot be customized. We appreciate your understanding as we bake each order fresh and made to order.
Perfect For:
Gifting • Celebrations • Family Gatherings • Office Treats • Sharing with Friends • Treating Yourself
Overall rating: 5.0 / 5 from 12 reviews.
The picture I shared… I had a dozen of your cookies there about a week ago… They are gone. They are delicious! I actually froze them and I have three left in the freezer… Saving them for a special occasion like coming home from work tonight. Ha ha ha.
Saw a recommendation in a local group and ordered immediately. Beautiful variety, generous size, and I don't have a favorite.
These cream pies are revolutionary!!!
These are amazing!
What is this sorcery? After recieving a gift box of these and inhaling an entire oatling (oh lawd they thick🤤) I immediately started calculating how many more I could buy without anyone judging me. The cookies are soft and a bit chewy with warm home baked flavors, the filling is fluffy moist and balanced, and the overall experience was decadent and divine. Beware, these heavenly treats may cause fights. I had to fight off the family for the last one. Lovely packaging and i was delighted to recieve these as a gift and cant wait to now gift others. The oatlings are unique, impressive and fabulous. No explanation other than it's got to be Witchcraft. ✨️🪄
Every flavor felt distinct instead of tasting like the same base cookie. Highly Recommend.
The socials intrigued me, so I placed an order. This is the box to order when you cannot decide. The portions were generous, everything tasted fresh, and the packaging held up well. Perfect with coffee.
The first bite surprised me. We cut each one into pieces and did a full family taste test. The texture was soft and indulgent without feeling heavy. Chocolate Chip and Original were the family favorites.
Ordered for the family and barely got one. This is the box to order when you cannot decide. My favorite was the coconut, it is a very light and subtle flavor.
Honestly? The assortment made it easy to find out which full box to order next. Will buy the Pecan flavor 6-pack next time.
My daughter saw an Instagram reel and insisted I ordered. The pecan fans, coconut fans, and chocolate people were all happy. Although my daughter loved the chocolate chip the best.
Unbelievable!
